Spice and Everything Nice Mulled Cider Courtesy of Maker’s Mark Bourbon. Ingredients1 cup Maker’s Mark bourbon4 cups apple cider1 thinly-sliced lemon6 clove½ tsp ground allspice2 small sticks of cinnamonInstructionsCombine Maker's Mark and apple cider. Add lemon, cloves, ground allspice, and cinnamon sticks. Heat to boiling and serve.